Impact of alcohol consumption on young people - A systematic review of published reviews

Dorothy Newbury-Birch, Janet Walker, Leah Avery, Fiona Beyer, Nicola Brown, Katherine Jackson, Catherine A Lock, Ruth McGovern, Eileen Kaner

Research output: Book/ReportCommissioned report

Abstract

This review of reviews relating to the impact of alcohol consumption on young people was undertaken between May and October 2008 by a research team based at the Institute of Health and Society at Newcastle University. The work was commissioned by the Department for Children, Schools and Families (DCSF) - Tender No: eor/sbu/2008/007. Aims and Objectives: The aim of the study was to undertake a systematic review of the published review literature and summarise the evidence on the harms and benefits of alcohol consumption for children and young people. In this process we assessed the quality of the evidence in this field and its relevance to a UK population. We also identified gaps in the research which need to be addressed. Methods and Limitations: After a systematic search of the published evidence, 162 eligible reviews were found. These reviews were graded in terms of methodological quality and the strength of the conclusions that could be drawn from them. In the final narrative, 102 reviews were summarised to consider the impact of drinking on young people. The unused reviews consisted of duplicate material, older reviews and/or those of poorer methodological quality. This report takes the form of a narrative summary of the reviews’ findings. For ease of reading, references are presented using the Vancouver system in which each one is represented in the text by a unique number and then all are ordered numerically in a reference list at the end of the report. The evidence-base included many older reviews and there was a preponderance of research from the USA. In addition, the literature focused on adolescents and older teenagers but there was little information about prepubescent children. As a result, this body of work has limited generalisability to contemporary drinking by young people in England, particularly in younger children. Moreover, many of the reviews were methodologically weak and so it is not possible to discount bias from their findings. Lastly, most of the reviews were based on cross-sectional research which is unable to determine a causal link between risk factors and alcohol misuse, or indeed, between alcohol misuse and specific health or social consequences. It is not clear whether current adult guidance on low risk drinking is pertinent to young people or if specific recommendations are required for individuals who are in the midst of ongoing physiological and emotional development. The review has confirmed that there is a lack of good review evidence available about the impact of drinking on children and young people. However, an absence of evidence in this field does not mean that there is evidence of no impact of alcohol on such individuals. Despite the methodological weakness of research in this field, there is a large body of evidence which reports consistent trends between alcohol use and a range of adverse effects. This convergence allows us to draw credible conclusions about the impact of drinking on young people (particularly around or following puberty). Concluding remarks: There are many adverse consequences of drinking alcohol during childhood and adolescence which would seem to outweigh the modest number of positive impacts. Overall, it seems that delaying the age of alcohol initiation and limiting the amount drunk by young people is likely to enhance their health and well-being. The review literature has significant evidence gaps in the area of alcohol use by, and its consequences in, children and young people. A key gap is the lack of information about the precise amounts of alcohol that lead to adverse consequences. Also the majority of the evidence in this field relates to older youth (adolescents and college/university students). There is a real need for more research relating to younger children, since it is clear that alcohol drinking can and does occur prior to puberty in some UK children. This study has been constrained by the material that is currently available in published reviews. More progress is likely to be made by a systematic review of primary data in this field. However, there is also a clear need for more well-designed prospective studies in UK populations which measure alcohol use with precision and which characterise the range of possible adverse effects of drinking. There is also a requirement, in population studies, for multivariate analysis of key predictor variables in such a way that can control for possible confounding factors. Lastly, there is a need for longitudinal studies that follow-up younger people who drink to identify impacts over the longer term.
Original languageEnglish
PublisherDepartment of Children, Schools and Families
Publication statusPublished - 2009

Fingerprint

Alcohol Drinking
Alcohols
Drinking
Research
Puberty
Health
Population
England
Longitudinal Studies
Reading
Multivariate Analysis
Prospective Studies
Students

Cite this

Newbury-Birch, D., Walker, J., Avery, L., Beyer, F., Brown, N., Jackson, K., ... Kaner, E. (2009). Impact of alcohol consumption on young people - A systematic review of published reviews. Department of Children, Schools and Families.
Newbury-Birch, Dorothy ; Walker, Janet ; Avery, Leah ; Beyer, Fiona ; Brown, Nicola ; Jackson, Katherine ; Lock, Catherine A ; McGovern, Ruth ; Kaner, Eileen. / Impact of alcohol consumption on young people - A systematic review of published reviews. Department of Children, Schools and Families, 2009.
@book{ffb1819e331041e695610966335fec30,
title = "Impact of alcohol consumption on young people - A systematic review of published reviews",
abstract = "This review of reviews relating to the impact of alcohol consumption on young people was undertaken between May and October 2008 by a research team based at the Institute of Health and Society at Newcastle University. The work was commissioned by the Department for Children, Schools and Families (DCSF) - Tender No: eor/sbu/2008/007. Aims and Objectives: The aim of the study was to undertake a systematic review of the published review literature and summarise the evidence on the harms and benefits of alcohol consumption for children and young people. In this process we assessed the quality of the evidence in this field and its relevance to a UK population. We also identified gaps in the research which need to be addressed. Methods and Limitations: After a systematic search of the published evidence, 162 eligible reviews were found. These reviews were graded in terms of methodological quality and the strength of the conclusions that could be drawn from them. In the final narrative, 102 reviews were summarised to consider the impact of drinking on young people. The unused reviews consisted of duplicate material, older reviews and/or those of poorer methodological quality. This report takes the form of a narrative summary of the reviews’ findings. For ease of reading, references are presented using the Vancouver system in which each one is represented in the text by a unique number and then all are ordered numerically in a reference list at the end of the report. The evidence-base included many older reviews and there was a preponderance of research from the USA. In addition, the literature focused on adolescents and older teenagers but there was little information about prepubescent children. As a result, this body of work has limited generalisability to contemporary drinking by young people in England, particularly in younger children. Moreover, many of the reviews were methodologically weak and so it is not possible to discount bias from their findings. Lastly, most of the reviews were based on cross-sectional research which is unable to determine a causal link between risk factors and alcohol misuse, or indeed, between alcohol misuse and specific health or social consequences. It is not clear whether current adult guidance on low risk drinking is pertinent to young people or if specific recommendations are required for individuals who are in the midst of ongoing physiological and emotional development. The review has confirmed that there is a lack of good review evidence available about the impact of drinking on children and young people. However, an absence of evidence in this field does not mean that there is evidence of no impact of alcohol on such individuals. Despite the methodological weakness of research in this field, there is a large body of evidence which reports consistent trends between alcohol use and a range of adverse effects. This convergence allows us to draw credible conclusions about the impact of drinking on young people (particularly around or following puberty). Concluding remarks: There are many adverse consequences of drinking alcohol during childhood and adolescence which would seem to outweigh the modest number of positive impacts. Overall, it seems that delaying the age of alcohol initiation and limiting the amount drunk by young people is likely to enhance their health and well-being. The review literature has significant evidence gaps in the area of alcohol use by, and its consequences in, children and young people. A key gap is the lack of information about the precise amounts of alcohol that lead to adverse consequences. Also the majority of the evidence in this field relates to older youth (adolescents and college/university students). There is a real need for more research relating to younger children, since it is clear that alcohol drinking can and does occur prior to puberty in some UK children. This study has been constrained by the material that is currently available in published reviews. More progress is likely to be made by a systematic review of primary data in this field. However, there is also a clear need for more well-designed prospective studies in UK populations which measure alcohol use with precision and which characterise the range of possible adverse effects of drinking. There is also a requirement, in population studies, for multivariate analysis of key predictor variables in such a way that can control for possible confounding factors. Lastly, there is a need for longitudinal studies that follow-up younger people who drink to identify impacts over the longer term.",
author = "Dorothy Newbury-Birch and Janet Walker and Leah Avery and Fiona Beyer and Nicola Brown and Katherine Jackson and Lock, {Catherine A} and Ruth McGovern and Eileen Kaner",
year = "2009",
language = "English",
publisher = "Department of Children, Schools and Families",

}

Newbury-Birch, D, Walker, J, Avery, L, Beyer, F, Brown, N, Jackson, K, Lock, CA, McGovern, R & Kaner, E 2009, Impact of alcohol consumption on young people - A systematic review of published reviews. Department of Children, Schools and Families.

Impact of alcohol consumption on young people - A systematic review of published reviews. / Newbury-Birch, Dorothy; Walker, Janet; Avery, Leah; Beyer, Fiona; Brown, Nicola; Jackson, Katherine; Lock, Catherine A ; McGovern, Ruth; Kaner, Eileen.

Department of Children, Schools and Families, 2009.

Research output: Book/ReportCommissioned report

TY - BOOK

T1 - Impact of alcohol consumption on young people - A systematic review of published reviews

AU - Newbury-Birch, Dorothy

AU - Walker, Janet

AU - Avery, Leah

AU - Beyer, Fiona

AU - Brown, Nicola

AU - Jackson, Katherine

AU - Lock, Catherine A

AU - McGovern, Ruth

AU - Kaner, Eileen

PY - 2009

Y1 - 2009

N2 - This review of reviews relating to the impact of alcohol consumption on young people was undertaken between May and October 2008 by a research team based at the Institute of Health and Society at Newcastle University. The work was commissioned by the Department for Children, Schools and Families (DCSF) - Tender No: eor/sbu/2008/007. Aims and Objectives: The aim of the study was to undertake a systematic review of the published review literature and summarise the evidence on the harms and benefits of alcohol consumption for children and young people. In this process we assessed the quality of the evidence in this field and its relevance to a UK population. We also identified gaps in the research which need to be addressed. Methods and Limitations: After a systematic search of the published evidence, 162 eligible reviews were found. These reviews were graded in terms of methodological quality and the strength of the conclusions that could be drawn from them. In the final narrative, 102 reviews were summarised to consider the impact of drinking on young people. The unused reviews consisted of duplicate material, older reviews and/or those of poorer methodological quality. This report takes the form of a narrative summary of the reviews’ findings. For ease of reading, references are presented using the Vancouver system in which each one is represented in the text by a unique number and then all are ordered numerically in a reference list at the end of the report. The evidence-base included many older reviews and there was a preponderance of research from the USA. In addition, the literature focused on adolescents and older teenagers but there was little information about prepubescent children. As a result, this body of work has limited generalisability to contemporary drinking by young people in England, particularly in younger children. Moreover, many of the reviews were methodologically weak and so it is not possible to discount bias from their findings. Lastly, most of the reviews were based on cross-sectional research which is unable to determine a causal link between risk factors and alcohol misuse, or indeed, between alcohol misuse and specific health or social consequences. It is not clear whether current adult guidance on low risk drinking is pertinent to young people or if specific recommendations are required for individuals who are in the midst of ongoing physiological and emotional development. The review has confirmed that there is a lack of good review evidence available about the impact of drinking on children and young people. However, an absence of evidence in this field does not mean that there is evidence of no impact of alcohol on such individuals. Despite the methodological weakness of research in this field, there is a large body of evidence which reports consistent trends between alcohol use and a range of adverse effects. This convergence allows us to draw credible conclusions about the impact of drinking on young people (particularly around or following puberty). Concluding remarks: There are many adverse consequences of drinking alcohol during childhood and adolescence which would seem to outweigh the modest number of positive impacts. Overall, it seems that delaying the age of alcohol initiation and limiting the amount drunk by young people is likely to enhance their health and well-being. The review literature has significant evidence gaps in the area of alcohol use by, and its consequences in, children and young people. A key gap is the lack of information about the precise amounts of alcohol that lead to adverse consequences. Also the majority of the evidence in this field relates to older youth (adolescents and college/university students). There is a real need for more research relating to younger children, since it is clear that alcohol drinking can and does occur prior to puberty in some UK children. This study has been constrained by the material that is currently available in published reviews. More progress is likely to be made by a systematic review of primary data in this field. However, there is also a clear need for more well-designed prospective studies in UK populations which measure alcohol use with precision and which characterise the range of possible adverse effects of drinking. There is also a requirement, in population studies, for multivariate analysis of key predictor variables in such a way that can control for possible confounding factors. Lastly, there is a need for longitudinal studies that follow-up younger people who drink to identify impacts over the longer term.

AB - This review of reviews relating to the impact of alcohol consumption on young people was undertaken between May and October 2008 by a research team based at the Institute of Health and Society at Newcastle University. The work was commissioned by the Department for Children, Schools and Families (DCSF) - Tender No: eor/sbu/2008/007. Aims and Objectives: The aim of the study was to undertake a systematic review of the published review literature and summarise the evidence on the harms and benefits of alcohol consumption for children and young people. In this process we assessed the quality of the evidence in this field and its relevance to a UK population. We also identified gaps in the research which need to be addressed. Methods and Limitations: After a systematic search of the published evidence, 162 eligible reviews were found. These reviews were graded in terms of methodological quality and the strength of the conclusions that could be drawn from them. In the final narrative, 102 reviews were summarised to consider the impact of drinking on young people. The unused reviews consisted of duplicate material, older reviews and/or those of poorer methodological quality. This report takes the form of a narrative summary of the reviews’ findings. For ease of reading, references are presented using the Vancouver system in which each one is represented in the text by a unique number and then all are ordered numerically in a reference list at the end of the report. The evidence-base included many older reviews and there was a preponderance of research from the USA. In addition, the literature focused on adolescents and older teenagers but there was little information about prepubescent children. As a result, this body of work has limited generalisability to contemporary drinking by young people in England, particularly in younger children. Moreover, many of the reviews were methodologically weak and so it is not possible to discount bias from their findings. Lastly, most of the reviews were based on cross-sectional research which is unable to determine a causal link between risk factors and alcohol misuse, or indeed, between alcohol misuse and specific health or social consequences. It is not clear whether current adult guidance on low risk drinking is pertinent to young people or if specific recommendations are required for individuals who are in the midst of ongoing physiological and emotional development. The review has confirmed that there is a lack of good review evidence available about the impact of drinking on children and young people. However, an absence of evidence in this field does not mean that there is evidence of no impact of alcohol on such individuals. Despite the methodological weakness of research in this field, there is a large body of evidence which reports consistent trends between alcohol use and a range of adverse effects. This convergence allows us to draw credible conclusions about the impact of drinking on young people (particularly around or following puberty). Concluding remarks: There are many adverse consequences of drinking alcohol during childhood and adolescence which would seem to outweigh the modest number of positive impacts. Overall, it seems that delaying the age of alcohol initiation and limiting the amount drunk by young people is likely to enhance their health and well-being. The review literature has significant evidence gaps in the area of alcohol use by, and its consequences in, children and young people. A key gap is the lack of information about the precise amounts of alcohol that lead to adverse consequences. Also the majority of the evidence in this field relates to older youth (adolescents and college/university students). There is a real need for more research relating to younger children, since it is clear that alcohol drinking can and does occur prior to puberty in some UK children. This study has been constrained by the material that is currently available in published reviews. More progress is likely to be made by a systematic review of primary data in this field. However, there is also a clear need for more well-designed prospective studies in UK populations which measure alcohol use with precision and which characterise the range of possible adverse effects of drinking. There is also a requirement, in population studies, for multivariate analysis of key predictor variables in such a way that can control for possible confounding factors. Lastly, there is a need for longitudinal studies that follow-up younger people who drink to identify impacts over the longer term.

UR - https://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/12292/

M3 - Commissioned report

BT - Impact of alcohol consumption on young people - A systematic review of published reviews

PB - Department of Children, Schools and Families

ER -

Newbury-Birch D, Walker J, Avery L, Beyer F, Brown N, Jackson K et al. Impact of alcohol consumption on young people - A systematic review of published reviews. Department of Children, Schools and Families, 2009.